Emotional while listening...

Posted: 4/22/2018 2:17:16 PM
tinkeringdude

From: Germany

Joined: 8/30/2014

Oh, race condition. I'll try that next time, now I pasted everything in an editor which strips off special characters and re-did the links. Not sure what went wrong the first timne, but I think it had to do with first clicking "reply with quote", and then deciding I didn't like the way the quoting looked and removing it with the delete key. Apparently omitting invisible magic characters.

Posted: 4/22/2018 5:49:33 PM
dewster

From: Northern NJ, USA

Joined: 2/17/2012

Thanks for those nice links!  But I fear opera is a acquired taste I may never completely acquire.  Orchestral stuff too.  I do like a good pipe organ and choir now and then, and more intimate strings like quartets and such are nice.  Operas and orchestras often strike me as bombastic.  And (my fault) I have this thing against overly trained voices.  I generally prefer female singers (and songwriters) as they tend to come across as more emotionally natural and open, males are IMO too often prone to forced, fakey vocal stylings that grate.  (Not all females nor males, of course, but it seems like a trend or tendency to me.)

"If it's a slow start (dynamics) into a note what you mean, then I'm not sure, as it depends on the music (what's written or customary to style) what a singer will do (unless they're indulging)."  - tinkeringdude

Here (link) is the piece backwards.  It starts out kind of strange, but there are sections that sound fairly natural to me if you can ignore the reversed background.  If nothing else it highlights how quick and pronounced her note endings are.

"Hehe, but only for so long! The short time that it is perceived as transitional, maybe, but our brains can apparently interpolate the center frequency if the supposed pitch has been roughly steady for a while, and if that center is off, it's off. Opera melody lines are, on average, a lot more stretched out in time* than pop singing, so, you can't hide for very long."

I know what you're saying, and I haven't researched this, but it's my feeling that vibrato makes exact pitch sensing much more difficult for us humans.

Reversed envelope and vibrato are ways I think to effectively mask pitch issues to some degree, though of course they are useful in other ways as seasoning techniques, so I'm not necessarily accusing anyone of anything nefarious, just making that observation.

Posted: 4/22/2018 6:44:37 PM
ILYA

From: Theremin Motherland

Joined: 11/13/2005

a few years ago my kid expressed emotions on some song by this drawing

The song is tittled "the drunked sun".

Yesterday this song was performed on tv again, by another singer and in a slightly different interpretation:

https://youtu.be/23WyPLIKDG8


You must be logged in to post a reply. Please log in or register for a new account.